The choice depends on what the address must do. At 20 letters and 3 parcels a month, the printed USPS total is $510 a year before forwarding, while a virtual plan prints $56.99 a year and iPostal1 reaches $639.00 once its scans are added, both before forwarding. A PO Box wins on low volume, USPS mail and a lock; a virtual mailbox wins on a street address, couriers and remote scanning.
What a virtual mailbox is, and what a PO Box is not
A virtual mailbox is a paid box at a private mail centre, a Commercial Mail Receiving Agency, a CMRA under USPS rules, which must tag your box with "PMB" or "#". You get a street address, and the operator scans, holds, forwards or shreds what arrives.
A PO Box is a locked box in a USPS lobby, not a street address: Publication 28 says a box number stands alone unless the location offers street addressing.
What each costs at the same mail volume
The table prices one year: 20 letters and 3 parcels a month, every letter content-scanned, letters forwarded monthly, each parcel as it comes. A Medium box (Size 3) fits a week of letters and a flat; parcels that do not fit go to a locker or notice. The USPS column is the Group 1 three-month price × 4 plus the key deposit; each virtual column a printed yearly price where one exists, otherwise the cheapest month × 12, plus scans.
| Option | Plan or box, 12 months | Item cap | Scans (12-month cost or allowance) | Forwarding | Printed total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| USPS Medium (Size 3), Group 1 | $126 × 4 = $504 | none | none by USPS | not printed | $504 + $6 refundable deposit = $510 |
| iPostal1, cheapest plan | $99.00 printed yearly | 30, fits | $2.25/order × 20 orders × 12 = $540.00 | not printed | $639.00 + forwarding |
| Anytime Mailbox, cheapest plan | $56.99 printed yearly | 15, 8 short | $1.00/page × 20 pages × 12 = $240.00 | no handling fee | $296.99 + overage |
| PhysicalAddress.com, annual plan | $7.98 × 12 = $95.76 | 30 envelope scans | 10/mo included, $0.20 each over | not printed | $119.76 + forwarding |
| PostScan Mail, cheapest plan | $4.95 × 12 = $59.40 | no cap, $3/item | $2.00/envelope × 20 × 12 = $480.00 | $2.00 first item, $0.50 each more, plus shipping | $59.40 + $480 scans + $3/item + forwarding |
| Traveling Mailbox, cheapest plan | $15 × 12 = $180.00 | 40 | 35 included, $0.50/page over | postage + $2 a shipment | $180.00 + forwarding |
Lowest published month: iPostal1 Green $9.99, Anytime Bronze $4.99 (printed yearly at $56.99), PhysicalAddress $7.98 (its 20% off annual plans banner not applied), PostScan basic Locker $4.95, Traveling Basic $15. Prices vary by mailbox location at iPostal1, Anytime Mailbox and PostScan Mail. No provider prints a setup fee.
USPS moves box mail by Change of Address, but prints no forwarding price. Letters cost nothing at the box; an oversize parcel costs nothing extra, a clerk leaves a locker key or notice.
iPostal1's scans, $540, are over five times its $99 yearly plan, since scans sit outside it. Anytime Mailbox takes 15 items against 23, charges no forwarding handling fee, and leaves overage unprinted. PhysicalAddress includes 10 content scans a month, 10 short of 20, at $0.20 each; PostScan Mail charges $2.00 an envelope and Traveling Mailbox $0.50 a page over 35.
On plan cost alone, Anytime is lowest at $56.99, PostScan next at $59.40 and PhysicalAddress at $95.76, each with scans still to add; iPostal1 is highest, $639.00 with its scans counted. USPS omits forwarding, every virtual column setup.
The address: box number or street address
A PO Box alone gives "PO Box 123, City, State ZIP". That works for USPS letters, not for forms, maps or couriers.
Some locations sell a fix: Street Addressing Service, offered only at Premium PO Box locations in competitive fee groups, lets you put the Post Office street address, "#" and the box number on the mail. You must opt in and sign; "Suite" and "Apt." are banned, and wrong-format mail can go back.
Even then USPS says it may not serve as your physical residence or place of business in legal documents; misuse can close the box.
A CMRA address is a real street address but an agent's, carrying "PMB" or "#". The IRS accepts a PMB as a Post Office substitute and asks for the number at the end of the street line with no "#": "102 S. 38 PMB 3".
Parcels, couriers and what each will accept
A plain PO Box takes only USPS mail; a UPS, FedEx or Amazon driver cannot put a parcel in it. An item too big or needing a signature gets a locker key, a counter notice or a Smart Locker code; the counter item is collected, not redelivered.
Street Addressing widens intake to carrier parcels that meet USPS mailing standards, but nothing over 70 pounds, no wine or other alcohol, nothing USPS prohibits; a parcel that breaks the rules is refused or held.
A virtual service is built to take carrier parcels; Traveling Mailbox says its address takes UPS and FedEx. Time is the catch: iPostal1 holds packages 30 days under 1,728 cubic inches, 10 days from 1,728 to 4,895 and 5 days at or above 4,896, PhysicalAddress a week.
Hours and access
A PO Box is reached in person. USPS advertises 24/7 access at most Post Offices, but 24-hour lobby access is a select-location feature, so check hours; outside them it is shut.
A virtual mailbox is reached from a screen: you see the scan whenever you log in. Staffed hours are the operator's and the pages do not list them.
Filing a business and opening a bank account
USPS lets a business rent a PO Box: mark "Business/Organization Use" on PS Form 1093, apply under the ID rules, and everyone receiving mail shows two IDs on request. The box gives no street address unless Street Addressing is offered, and even then not a legal place of business.
For the IRS, a PMB works: the agency treats PMB companies as Post Office substitutes and wants the number at the end of the street line with no "#".
States and banks differ; a box-only address is the weakest, some want a physical address or registered agent. PhysicalAddress bundles a free registered agent, not proof. Confirm both.
Form 1583 and CMRA status
Every virtual service is a CMRA, which comes with paperwork: PS Form 1583, "Application for Delivery of Mail Through Agent", checked against your ID and permanent address.
You sign in person or on live video with the agent, or before a notary. A business needs an officer's signature and title, and each adult files separately.
A PO Box runs on PS Form 1093 and two IDs. The trade is privacy: the CMRA ends up holding your ID and your address.
Privacy and theft
Both keep mail off your doorstep. A PO Box keeps it behind a lock; the deposit is $6 per key as of October 4, 2026, refunded when returned; new competitive-location customers skip it for two keys.
A virtual service keeps it behind a counter: staff hold it until you decide. PhysicalAddress and Traveling Mailbox include free shredding, so a discard does not sit in a bin with your name. Staff still see your mail.
Signature on File is free at premium competitive locations and lets USPS sign for Priority Mail Express, insured mail over $500 and Signature Confirmation, not Registered or Certified.
How to set each one up
For a PO Box: pick a size (X-Small, Size 1, to X-Large, Size 5; not every office keeps all); apply online at 18 or over, completing PS Form 1093 as Business/Organization Use or Residential/Personal Use; show two current IDs, one with a photo and one traceable to your address; pay the term and the $6 per-key deposit as of October 4, 2026, and ask about Street Addressing and Signature on File.
For a virtual mailbox: choose a provider and read the item cap and storage days; pick a plan and complete PS Form 1583, with an officer signing for a business; verify your ID on video with the agent or before a notary, every adult filing separately; pay, and ask what the first invoice adds: no provider prints a setup fee.
Which one fits your case
- A locked box for USPS mail you collect. Low volume, in town, no scanning, no courier parcels. X-Small boxes at $21 a quarter in Group 7 or $22 in Group 6 as of October 4, 2026 work out to $84 or $88 a year; the cheapest virtual plan is $56.99.
- A street address with remote handling. Orders, invoices and parcels from any carrier, handled from another city. A CMRA does this; a box alone does not.
- A business needing a street address and scanning. Virtual, with the PMB entered the IRS way, and a physical address kept for filings and banks.
- A move. A box holds mail while you pack, but with Street Addressing you file a Change of Address for each format. A virtual service forwards at an unprinted price.
USPS prices and how to rent
The full USPS schedule prints every size and fee group, the key and lock fees and the Group E free-box rule, plus the steps to rent.
The UPS Store as a third option
The UPS Store sells personal mailboxes with PMB addresses at franchise-set prices; its stores also take parcels.
The full provider price list
Virtual mailbox cost lists every plan these five providers print, what each includes and every per-item fee.
Questions
Which is cheaper if the mail volume is low
A PO Box in a cheap fee group. A three-month X-Small box is $50 in Group 1, $29 in Group 4 and $21 in Group 7 as of October 4, 2026, with no monthly item cap. A $4.99 virtual plan takes 15 items before an unprinted overage.
Can a virtual mailbox receive packages
Yes, from private carriers as well as USPS, its main advantage over a plain PO Box. Storage is time-limited: iPostal1 prints 30 days under 1,728 cubic inches, 10 days from 1,728 to 4,895 and 5 days at or above 4,896; PhysicalAddress prints one week, PostScan Mail 7 days free and Traveling Mailbox 30 days free.
Can a PO Box be used as a business address
As a mailing address, yes: a business marks "Business/Organization Use" on PS Form 1093. As a street address, only with Street Addressing, using "#" plus the box number, no "Suite" or "Apt.". Even then USPS will not let it stand as the legal place of business.